Board index Off Topic Board Off Topic Discussion Did Jesus exist? Italian court to decide

Did Jesus exist? Italian court to decide

Here, anything goes. Talk about anything that you would like to talk about!

Post January 9th, 2006, 12:46 am
Coasterkidmwm User avatar
True Addicts
True Addicts

Posts: 12283
Points on hand: 8,049.10 Points
Bank: 15,000.00 Points
Location: Illinois, USA
Originally posted by Jakizle

I dont think that comment was neccisary IntaminFan


I think it was completely necessary. Some churches are practically a terrorist group. I am probably a little harsh on the issue given that a 6 yr old relative of mine died of pnemonia because my dumbass relgious relatives sent her to one of those Christian medicine places. Had they taken her to an actual hospitol they could have given her antibiotics or something instead of a 5 hr bullshit prayer circle or something.

Another thing, I cannot for the life of me understand how that stupid Intelligent Design idea got passed. It contains no science whatsoever and doesn't make any sense. The old geocentric universe theory makes more sense than this one.

There is no evidence for anything that happened in the Bible except the fact tht it writeen on a piece of paper. Most of the new testament was written at least 50 years after the events took place, which is enough time for word of mouth stories to get almost completely made up. Ever played telephone?

Good for this guy, I personally hate the church and all of the lies they told me when I was younger about other religions that got me into MAJOR trouble. I want my cousin back, and I'm sick of the Jesus poop.

Post January 9th, 2006, 12:51 am

Posts: 5286
Points on hand: 3,059.00 Points
Location: USA
^^You mentioned not being an obsessed christian activist...but theres a problem with that. If you never become obsessed with God and Jesus to the point where it doesnt make you want to tell other people, then you are just luke warm. You arent being useful at all if you arent first loving everyone and second making sure they know where the love comes from.

As for IF's comment, expected and sucks to know that because my beliefs differ from his that I suck. A pity that I have nothing against him yet, I suck. :

I dont see where this guy isnt getting proof. I have seen both documentaries and read articles alike that prove Jesus existed. He is mentioned in more than one historical book and there is substantial evidence that He did exist. Whether or not you beleive He did what is recorded is up to each person but His existance is recoreded in more places than just the Bible.


Pump - But to clarify, I do agree that too many people are too far conservative or too far liberal. If you were to place Jesus among those 2 He would fall in the middle. He was neither too conservative nor too liberal but He was a bit of both. He was conservative in ways such as Him never backing down or sacrificing His beliefs. He never compromized what He said nor did He ever do anyything different from what was said. He was liberal though in ways such as Him going to the "bad peoples" houses (tax collectors, prostitutes, lepers, etc) and having meals with them. He did things that were very, very unortodox from current beliefs.

So on one side he was never failing in His word but He also was doing alot that followers of that day NEVER thought of doing because they were too conservative.


Humans do the same thing today. One group of people says that one generation is too liberal, which is true while that generation calls the others too conservative...which is also true. Where am I going with this?

We have to go out and meet peoples needs. Jesus worked on Maslows Heirarchy of needs. He knew that the only way He could get His message across to people was to meet their needs. Check just about every single time He talked or preached His word. He ALWAYS met the persons needs first. When someone was sick, He didnt tell them first how to believe in Him and follow Him. No, first He healed them. When someone was starving (or in His case, thousands) He gave them food and then taught. He never reached out to individuals first without meeting their needs because He knew that if He did just start preaching to someone who was hurting from an illness, they could care less about what He was saying because all they were worried about was their illness. But if He heals them first, well now they just had a miracle performed on them AND they now have their needs met which shows that He cares about them which in turn makes them listen to what He may have to say.


All humans react this way. Everyone has to have their needs met first before they really lsiten to someone. Think about the people in your life who have made the biggest impact on you. I would bet that majority of those people care about you and you know it. Otherwise, why listen to them? If they dont care about you, why care about them right?

Thats why you cant be a closet Christian and just stay out of peoples way to avoid being too overbearing. Its rather quite simple. Just go and meet peoples needs, care about and for them and they will be much more willing to talk and listen to you than say, those overbearing people who just try to shove it down peoples throats.


As for the topic, I already said proof is out there from other texts and documents. Its just a shame that MOST texts that predate the modern era were written more as stories than as "historical documents" that we know today so its rarely taken as legitimate historical data. but thats how things were communicated back before our modern era - by story, not by boring historical texts.


Originally posted by Coasterkidmwm
Most of the new testament was written at least 50 years after the events took place


Incorrect. They were written anywhere from 18-30 years. Only the latest of the documents were written 50 years or later. Plus they were written by eye witnesses. Also, many texts were already written and later writers quoted text from those.

So basically it would be like you going to a football game, recording the events. Then me coming along, copying your recording and then quoting you as a first person eye witness. Its not like the people who wrote it were descendants or descendants of descendants or anything. Majority were eye witnesses or quoted existing texts.


Plus you still miss the point if you are trying to look at the bible as pure historical book. As I said, it was originally written as stories of actual events, not a history book. When you look at it from that perspective it becomes alot clearer.

Post January 9th, 2006, 1:14 am

Posts: 2171
Points on hand: 1,469.00 Points
Location: La Verne, CA, USA
Nice meaningful post Real.

I personally am a "nonbeliever"(athiest makes it sound awful). You guys who have "seen documentaries and read articles"....That doesent mean its true, You can find anyway to play with words and and stretch facts to make Jesus real or unreal. I do believe that Jesus existed. I think he was a great dude, did good stuff, people looked up him, And so on. Then some people wrote a book about him, and said what is right and what is wrong and made a system of living up which is now christianity. Over the years people adapted to this and started to follow it and its grown to one of the larges t religions in the world. People, Its all about faith, not about whether jesus existed or about whether some dude had the badass powers to part and an ocean. People turn to religion to have something to live for. Thats what its all about. Thats why other regions of the world have different beliefs, Mankind strives on purpose. Everyone wants to know why they are here. Some people choose not to believe in a God, like me. I have reasons which I think im here. Let everyone think what they want and get along...

Post January 9th, 2006, 1:49 am

Posts: 337
Points on hand: 2,304.00 Points
Location: AL, USA
I am a christian, and people can believe what they want, and as long as they have set moral standards for themselves then I have no problem with that. But when people come and bash people's beliefs, that is just disrespectful and heartless.

Post January 9th, 2006, 1:50 am

Posts: 5286
Points on hand: 3,059.00 Points
Location: USA
You are right about it being on faith.

The people who wrote the book didnt make up the style of living...it was copied from Jesus. Again, eye-witness accounts. It wasnt telephone and it wasnt passed down the grapevine other than through other texts which were almost always quoted nearly word for word. Unfortunate for alot of people that unless its an autobiography they wont believe it, but hey, thats culture.

However, I think you are stretching it when you say that people turn to religion to have something to live for. Plus, Christianity isnt a religion. That is, real Christianity. Not this so-called progressive-culture christianity crap thats going around. I dont believe nor do I follow a religion. I follow Christ.

I also dont follow it just to give my life meaning. If that were the case, then wouldnt that be a pretty empty? I dont see that as being a real cause.


Some people turn to it just to have meaning. Those people are usually the ones seen as fake. Then there are those who have seen more and felt more than just the need to have my life worth something. I have a girlfriend of almost 5 years I could live for. I have a family I could live for. I even have myself.


Anyways, just wanted to clarify that. I hear it alot and its somewhat of a cop-out to say that people run to "religion" for a single reason or even a plethora of reasons. I didnt find God, He found me. I certainly wasnt looking for him.



Fun-Fact - Islam and Christianity come from the same bloodline. Christianity comes from Isaac, son of Abraham. Ishmal is where Islam comes from...also son of the same Abraham. The only difference is that Isaac was made a promise from God that wasnt promised to Ishmal. So really the war between islam and christianity is a war within its own family. How civil, eh?

Post January 9th, 2006, 2:14 am

Posts: 404
Points on hand: 1,600.00 Points
Location: Los Angleles, CA, USA
even if there is no god or if jesus never existed or WHATEVER, there is no way this guy will win. the catholic church is so big and powerful, and has over 3 billion followers, and church and state have to be seperated in Italy, so it will never go through

Post January 9th, 2006, 2:38 am

Posts: 2171
Points on hand: 1,469.00 Points
Location: La Verne, CA, USA
Also to add to what I said. Its not just a Meaning or reason, its an explanation for life, The world is so mesmerizing and amazing people need an explanation for it. Thats why we thought up Religions, and Why we thought up evolution.

Post January 9th, 2006, 3:26 am

Posts: 5286
Points on hand: 3,059.00 Points
Location: USA
Well, I still disagree. I could very well live without knowing the explanation for how life was created. I dont really think its that useful considering I never read about Jesus getting into heated debates about how the Earth was created. He quoted what the Old Testament said but that wasnt His direct message.

However, this isnt to say that "religions" were not created to fill the void every human has. Many were and I agree with that. Ill say it again, I didnt come to know God because I was searching for anything.

Post January 9th, 2006, 5:14 am

Posts: 744
Points on hand: 2,685.00 Points
Location: Coon Rapids, MN, USA

I have to agree with you Real. I believe in God and Jesus Christ, but I am not religious to the point that I follow a religion. I respect other people's beliefs and I feel that they have a right to them.

Post January 9th, 2006, 7:07 am

Posts: 5626
Points on hand: 5,993.00 Points
Location: Millbrook, Alabama, USA

Originally posted by Iron Man

Hey TJ, I can't seem to find that topic. Would you mind assisting me?

Click the link I posted in my reply back on page 2 -- or at you talking about the religion thread? If so, that is here:

http://www.coasters2k.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=3649&

Post January 9th, 2006, 9:31 am

Posts: 2748
Points on hand: 4,830.00 Points
Location: Medinah, Il, USA

Originally posted by PumpMeUp

Shutup RRollergod, please there was no need for that, and im glad your a christian. Every site needs a topic like this IMO, as long as it does "not" get out of hand.


sorry if that sounded wrong i was on my PSP so i could type everything i wanted to say but i mean that there are so many religons that people agree with on this site, so than i thought people would fight what they believe in but i guess not so nevermind...

But this guy will never win and people would never believe in the outcome but really he got to court with this???

Post January 9th, 2006, 7:44 pm
coolbeans326 User avatar
Premium Member
Premium Member

Posts: 5229
Points on hand: 6,184.00 Points
Location: Portland, OR, USA

[quote[the guy is dead anyway, almost 2,000 years.....and all of us know that god or such does not excist, some just don't admit it[/quote]
All of us know that god exist, just some of us don't want to admit it....
You have some of the dumbest arguments. I mean, just some times you need to shut up.

Post January 9th, 2006, 7:54 pm

Posts: 5367
Points on hand: 1,916.00 Points
Location: San Antonio, Texas, USA

I tottaly respect others beliefs and religious. I think that it is beyond rudeness and so inconsiderate to bash others religioins. I have friends that are from all different nationalities and religions, but i dont go around saying, "Hey your a christian. You suck." These types of comment are not neciserey. It dissapointments me that someone would say some of things said about bashing other beiefes. Be considerate of other people. Cmon guys.

Post January 9th, 2006, 7:54 pm

Posts: 5286
Points on hand: 3,059.00 Points
Location: USA
Originally posted by coolbeans326

[quote[the guy is dead anyway, almost 2,000 years.....and all of us know that god or such does not excist, some just don't admit it

All of us know that god exist, just some of us don't want to admit it....
You have some of the dumbest arguments. I mean, just some times you need to shut up.
[/quote]

Actually its just those people loving to stir things up. Its not about whether or not people admit it or not. Infact, Id rather someone just say they didnt believe than to admit it but not care. Both are in the same boat. To believe in God and to follow Him are two completely different things. Its written that even the demons themselves know Jesus and God so that shouldnt be a suprise.

Post January 9th, 2006, 8:10 pm

Posts: 2171
Points on hand: 1,469.00 Points
Location: La Verne, CA, USA
Originally posted by Real


Ill say it again, I didnt come to know God because I was searching for anything.


Maybe not consiously....Would you tell me the story of how you came across him either in PM or here, just interested. [;)]

Also, to what you said ^ right above, Your right they are 2 very different things. I follow God, but do not believe in him...

Post January 9th, 2006, 8:13 pm

Posts: 5626
Points on hand: 5,993.00 Points
Location: Millbrook, Alabama, USA

Originally posted by Real

To believe in God and to follow Him are two completely different things. Its written that even the demons themselves know Jesus and God so that shouldnt be a suprise.

Actually, to be a stickler for the Word because that is my job, James Chapter 2 Verse 19 says, "You believe that there is one God. Good! Even the demons believe that ????????? and shudder."

At any rate, one day everything will be answered. And, if at the end of my life I discover I spent my life living for someone that does not exist -- I will have lost nothing except my time; which was spent in joyful celebration. However, for someone else to die and find out that Christians were right, they would lose everything, to include their very soul. It is a choice ...

The whole concept about this court hearing ... well, yeah, Pilate thought he was cute too and held a kangaroo-court hearing 2000 years ago as well, and once that hearing was over and the sentence carried out, the very ground shook, so much so that even a Roman soldier admitted that Jesus was who He said He was.

Mark 15:38-39 "The curtain of the temple was torn in two from top to bottom. And when the centurion, who stood there in front of Jesus, heard his cry and saw how he died, he said, "Surely this man was the Son of God!"

10 seconds after Pilate finally died naturally on Earth, he knew his choice had been made and realized exactly who Jesus of Nazareth was, as he stood before Him to hear the words "Depart from me, I never knew you." You choose who you'll believe, I already have. Italian court ruling, no Italian court ruling ... it does not matter. For one day I know where I shall live for all eternity; without a shadow of a doubt found anywhere in my being.

Post January 9th, 2006, 9:02 pm

Posts: 3018
Points on hand: 2,931.00 Points
Location: USA

Post January 9th, 2006, 9:12 pm

Posts: 288
Points on hand: 827.00 Points
Location: Omaha, Nebraska, USA
WHAT THE HELL, JUST LET THE GOD DAMN PEOPLE BELIEVE WHAT THEY WANT TO BELIEVE ! ! !


GOSH DANG !

Post January 9th, 2006, 9:21 pm

Posts: 5367
Points on hand: 1,916.00 Points
Location: San Antonio, Texas, USA

pretty much the exact same thing i said in my post above, just yours was in 16 words!

Post January 9th, 2006, 9:23 pm

Posts: 332
Points on hand: 5,058.00 Points
I haven't read the whole thread...but here's what I think:
Let people believe what they want, a case like this simply stuns me as to how it can come about. No court case can decide to change others beliefs, especially about religion. By far, this is the most pointless case I've come across, even if I am personally atheist and believe Jesus didn't exist.
For me, I could care less about the whole creation scene and what not, I could care less about where we go after death. I say just live where you are without pondering pointless (to me) things like this.

Post January 9th, 2006, 9:23 pm

Posts: 484
Points on hand: 2,897.00 Points
Location: USA

im getting tired about hearing about religion and things like that everyone will do what they think is right and believe what they want to believe nothing can change ones beliefs if they feel that strongly about it

Post January 9th, 2006, 10:15 pm
Coasterkidmwm User avatar
True Addicts
True Addicts

Posts: 12283
Points on hand: 8,049.10 Points
Bank: 15,000.00 Points
Location: Illinois, USA
Originally posted by CoAsTeRkRazY

go cathloics [pshades]


Corruption is awesome.

Post January 9th, 2006, 10:18 pm

Posts: 5626
Points on hand: 5,993.00 Points
Location: Millbrook, Alabama, USA


Post January 9th, 2006, 10:20 pm

Posts: 3018
Points on hand: 2,931.00 Points
Location: USA
that better not of been directed towards me?! was it?

Post January 9th, 2006, 10:32 pm

Posts: 5626
Points on hand: 5,993.00 Points
Location: Millbrook, Alabama, USA

Why? Feeling guilty? [lol]
It wasn't by the way, but if the shoe fits ... relax man.

PreviousNext

Return to Off Topic Discussion

 


  • Related topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post
cron